| Year | Students |
| 1986 | Gwen Connell, Cedarburg |
| 1987 | Deborah Coletti, Muskego |
| 1988 | John McKee, Premontre |
| 1989 | Pam Bernicke, Eau Claire Memorial Jeff Marks, Waupaca |
| 1990 | Nick Boegel, West Bend East Lori Funk, Waupaca |
| 1991 | Jason Bitiner, Hortonville Jeremy Radtke, Sheboygan South |
| 1992 | Robin Birr, Hortonville Melissa Krahn, Hortonville |
| 1993 | Wendy Roos, West Bend East Shannon Vosseller, Marquette |
| 1994 | Nicole Kralik, West Bend East Amy Witczak, New London |
| 1995 | Katie Kallstrom, Durand Julie Parmele, Waupaca |
| 1996 | Lynn Masfongelli, Sheboygan South Sean Waldheim, Marquette |
| 1997 | Ryan Billings, Sheboygan South Zach Schultz, Lodi |
| 1998 | Brooke Reinders, Milwaukee HS Arts Benjamin Schneider, Marquette Chad Richards, Waupaca |
| 1999 | Elizabeth Wautlet, Algoma† JoAnna Hix, Eau Claire North Colleen VanEpps, Waupaca* Jason Fischer, West Bend East |
| 2000 | Johnathan Blomberg, Waupaca† Emily Wacker, Brookfield East Sara Weisenbeck, Durand* B.J. Lanser, Marquette |
| 2001 | Kelley Marie Bender, New London Minette Detjen, Algoma† Tara Lynn Maus, New London Melanie Lynn Wick, Sheboygan North* |
| 2002 | Rachel Forbes, Brookfield East Nick Bubb, Sheboygan North Tessa Bysong, Durand* Frank Korf, Waupaca† |
| 2003 | Stefanie Jochman, Sheboygan North Michele Tellock, Hortonville Venus Cooper, New London Troy Vosseller, Marquette |
| 2004 | Tyler Beattie, Brookfield East Caitlin Madden, Sheboygan South† Anna-Lisa Dahlgren, Madison Memorial* Megan Harney, Wauwatosa West |
| 2005 | Thomas Schalmo, Brookfield East Julie Braker, Brookfield East Samuel Daly, Rufus King Mitchell Salm, St. Lawrence Seminary† |
| 2006 | Phillip Bridge, Brookfield East Emily Schwanke, Appleton East† Janani Iyangar, Madison Memorial Kelsey Palmer, Brookfield East* |
| 2007 | Asad Asad, Rufus King Amjad Asad, Rufus King Daniel Anderson, Appleton East† Rebecca Kesting, Sheboygan South* |
| 2008 | Nicholas Anderson, Eau Claire North Travis Glynn, New London† Heidi Wacker, Brookfield East Kirsten Wisniewski, Milwaukee HS of the Arts* |
| 2009 | Erin Britton, Sheboygan North Jacqueline Fuqua, Nicolet Cole Kantos, Waupaca† Jonathan Spence, Wauwatosa West Christopher Vosters, Brookfield East Bethany Zeitler, Algoma* |
| 2010 | Jared Beck, Cedarburg Katherine Burns, St. Croix Falls * Caroline Klinker, Brookfield East Ryan Manteufel, Waupaca † Valerie Shen, James Madison Memorial Alice Zhao, Sheboygan North |
| 2011 | McKenzie Bell, Appleton East Ryan Jaremczuk, St. Croix Falls Michael Meidl, Brookfield East Scott Memmel, Brookfield East Brandon Pakkebier, Sheboygan North Michelle Yang, James Madison Memorial |
| 2012 | Kaitlin Klann, Brookfield East Jordan Peschek, Hartford Union Mackenzie Ross, Sun Prairie Abhilash Sandireddy, James Madison Memorial Zackary Vrana, Brookfield East Jacob Wrasse, Durand |
| 2013 | Benjamin Bauman, Sun Prairie Eric Cummings, Waupaca Elizabeth Ehrler, Sun Prairie Kadesia Hill, Bradley Tech Kienan Knight-Boehm, Marquette University High School Kenneth Kosirowski, Marquette University High School |
| 2014 | John Ahn, Appleton East Sierra DuCharme-Hansen, Sun Prairie Nick Jungers, Waupaca Anh Le, Madison West Lauren Watchmaker, Homestead Troy Wildenberg, Appleton East |
| 2015 | Daksh Barghava, Sun Prairie Katherine Cichon, Appleton East Elizabeth Gartman, Sheboygan North Leon Pan, James Madison Memorial Cole Pankratz, Waupaca Kaleigh Pieroth, Arrowhead |
| 2016 | Alekh Kale, James Madison Memorial Jazmyn Kosier, Wauwatosa West Michaela Lemons, Appleton East Anne Liners, Ronald Reagan Diya Ramanathan, Arrowhead Union Hollis Rammer, Sheboygan South |
| 2017 | Erik Bakken, Appleton North Rachel Bednarowski, Appleton East Bailee Harper, Denmark Natalie Kasberger, Sheboygan North Erin Magoon, Sussex-Hamilton Dakota Marlega, Waupaca |
| 2018 | Urwa Ahmed, Franklin Elsbeth Bandli, Sun Prairie Isaac Hoeschen, Pius XI Tiffany Polzin, Denmark Claire Sawall, Appleton East Katherine Walsh, Madison West |
| 2019 | Madelyn Aamodt, West Bend East Emily Cash, Appleton West Emily Chu, Arrowhead Erin Gretzinger, Appleton East Garrick Hartley, Sauk Prairie Arjun Shreekumar, Brookfield East |
| 2020 | Emily Flood, Sun Prairie Morgan Klug, Homestead Weihang Li, Brookfield East Leah Metzger, James Madison Memorial Josef Rademacher, Madison West Rihana Zaiani, Ronald Reagan |
| 2021 | Emma Baumgartner, Cedarburg Lauren Broman, Wrightstown Samantha Hansche, Ronald Reagan Jacob Marx, Marquette University Amoolya Selvaraj, Brookfield East Tara Weber, Sun Prairie |
| 2022 | Dylan Christensen, Wrightstown Natalie Frank, Neenah Tatum Grambow, Appleton East Amanjot Kaur, Brookfield East Max Kiekhofer, Ronald Reagan Eliana Sauer, James Madison Memorial |
| 2023 | Parker DeDecker, Neenah Ethan Flood, Sun Prairie West Gino Feciskonin, Port Washington Hasti Ghasemivaghar, West Bend East Jasleen Kaur, Sussex-Hamilton Kate Pluta, Wauwatosa East |
| 2024 | Jessica Landers, Pius XI Jackson Nesbit, Sun Prairie East Henry Pahlow, Denmark Addison Peck, Oshkosh West Amber Radtke, Wrightstown Erica Rosner, Slinger |
* Marie Chelmo Memorial Scholarship
† Steinhorst Scholarship